There are many issues with young children on the Internet. Kids can post anything of themselves, post other people, and there are predators online. Governments are trying their best to help keep social media safe, but it’s hard to do when considering privacy. Should social media regulation for children be left to parents, or should governments do more to protect their citizens?
Social Media Restriction Policies
Recently, as of the writing of this article, the European Union (EU) has proposed the EU KIDS Act. This act severely restricts adolescent access to social media. Social media, being not so new anymore, has given people the reasons they need to think of it as harmful to their children. In this specific proposal, kids under thirteen wouldn’t be allowed to have social media accounts at all. Teens thirteen to fourteen would have “mini accounts” that can be managed through an adult account and have limited, age-appropriate features. Teens fifteen and up would be able to have their own accounts, but would still receive age-appropriate protections. However, this would be enforced through age verification, which raises questions about users' privacy, even though the proposal includes measures intended to protect it.
This act has been met with very mixed and polarized reactions. Some people think this should be completely left to the discretion of the parents, but some think it’s the only way to keep children safe because some parents are negligent or ignorant of technology. Does this seem like an extreme expansion of government into people’s lives, or is it worth it for the protection of our children?
Of course, apps have age restrictions, but they are incredibly easy to bypass. If they ask about your birthday, just put in a date that would make you an adult. If children are putting in their birthdays as adults, they may not receive the protections that laws require social media companies to follow when it comes to child users. For example, Texas has prohibited targeted advertising to known minors, while Florida has enacted restrictions on social media accounts for younger users. However, these protections can be difficult to apply when a minor has set their year of birth as 1970.
Privacy and Freedom Concerns
Many people, especially in America, don’t like the idea of all kids having to use photo ID for social media access. They see it as a threat to freedom and too big of an expansion of power for the government. People want and think they deserve the right to give their kids social media if they want to. It’s also uncomfortable for parents to think about their kids’ IDs being scanned and potentially stored in some type of database or wherever else.
Privacy is very important, especially when it comes to the Internet. Not many people want all their browsing habits and accounts to be easy to find from the scanning of their ID. Is this very unlikely? Yes, but it's still a risk people worry about. Some believe government regulations on social media users' information infringe on their freedoms. The hope these individuals have is that parents will watch their children and monitor what they're watching, but unfortunately, that's not always the case.
Is Safety Worth Anonymity?
The Internet has also become a place where people aren’t easily identifiable. It's part of its appeal. You can say or do anything, and there's a very small chance that people will find out who you are. With this, however, comes danger.
Many dangerous and predatory individuals take advantage of the Internet’s anonymity, but it's helpful for the everyday person as well. With things like stalkers and doxxing (putting someone's address on the Internet), it can help keep people safe. On the other hand, it also keeps predators safe as well. It makes you wonder: is it worth it to compromise one for the other?
The government is considered to be overexerting its power by some with these types of legislation. Some think this expansion of power is necessary to keep people safe. It's the age-old question: how far should we let the government go in hopes of protecting us?