Dress Codes, Discipline, and Discrimination

School dress codes have always been controversial, raising concerns about whether they truly encourage professionalism or if they are just a limitation on student expression. However, school dress codes carry a deeper need for control and maintenance of the status quo, as marginalized groups have been disproportionately affected by school dress code policies.

The History of School Dress Codes

School dress codes have long been a subject of debate, with the Vietnam War sparking this conversation. In the landmark case Tinker v. Des Moines, students wore black armbands in protest of the war. The school then planned to implement a policy that would require students to remove the armbands; if they refused, they could be suspended. This was a peaceful and symbolic protest, and the school’s actions violated the students’ First Amendment rights.

While this was an issue of freedom of speech and directly tied to politics, dress codes are heavily debated for reasons other than freedom of expression. Dress codes perpetuate harm and discrimination against marginalized communities, particularly girls and people of color, such as Black students. Two of many cases include Peltier v. Charter Day School and George v. Abbott.

Gender Discrimination in Dress Codes

A charter school in North Carolina required that all of the female students wear skirts in order to receive their education. The girls and their parents challenged this dress code as a violation of Title IX. The girls also stated that the dress code “sends the message that girls should be less active than boys and that they are more delicate than boys,” with the result that boys “feel empowered” and “in a position of power over girls.” This is because the skirt requirement imposed limitations on their activity and movement.

The girls were right to say those things. By restricting girls’ activity and movement due to the skirt requirement, they are put in a position where there is a very different expectation for them as girls. Additionally, the requirement for girls to wear skirts reflects not only an outdated fashion take but a more concerning gender expectation that has been perpetuated for centuries.

This requirement for girls to wear skirts is reminiscent of 19th-century women’s fashion: long skirts and corsets. These garments are incredibly restrictive, especially corsets. These were worn tightly to achieve the illusion of a small waist, a component of women’s beauty standards. As a result, some women experienced breathing difficulties and even damaged ribs. While the girls in North Carolina did not have such extreme limitations, their dress code was just as harmful in a different way. The school’s rationale for imposing this requirement was that girls are fragile vessels and wearing skirts would promote chivalry. This, of course, is an outdated belief, but an incredibly misogynistic one that degrades female students and belittles them.

Racial Discrimination and Hair Policies

Girls are not the only group of people to be disproportionately affected by school dress codes. In George v. Abbott, it is evident that Black students are also subject to these discriminatory policies. Barbers Hill Independent School District in Texas claimed that Daryl George violated its maximum hair length policy. Daryl claimed he had worn his hair in its natural state and in locs for years. When the school found that he violated its policy, he was given an in-school suspension. Later, his family filed another lawsuit against the state’s governor and attorney general, claiming that the school failed to act in accordance with the CROWN Act.

In another case, twins Mya and Deanna were punished for wearing box braids and extensions to school. The school, Mystic Valley Regional Charter School, claimed that the students violated its hair and makeup policy. Upon refusing to remove their extensions, the school gave them multiple hours of detention and threatened to suspend them. The twins were also barred from extracurricular activities, including the prom.

As seen in the cases of Daryl and Mya and Deanna, the schools issued punishments on the premise that the students were violating school policies. While students should face consequences for violating school rules, these policies seem to disproportionately affect Black students. Generally speaking, Black students are subject to discipline in schools at a rate that is much higher than non-Black students. The consequences that Daryl, Mya, and Deanna faced are also not proportional to their actions. Wearing a certain hairstyle shouldn’t get you suspended or banned from prom. It certainly raises concerns and questions about whether, if these were white students, we would even have these cases or a record of student discipline at all.

Dress Codes and the Status Quo

There is always the argument that dress codes are in place to prevent distractions and promote professionalism. However, dress codes not only disrupt students’ education when they are arbitrary, discriminatory, or impose unreasonable punishments; students who refuse to abide by the dress codes are disrupting the status quo.

Groups unfairly affected by school dress codes are those not initially allowed in these spaces. During slavery, Black individuals were prohibited from learning to read or write out of a desire for control; there was a growing fear that enslaved people could use these skills to gain their freedom. In Plessy v. Ferguson, segregation was legalized in schools, as long as the schools were separate but equal. However, the schools were not equal; the schools for Black students were underfunded, among other things, perpetuating the idea that Black students were not worthy of adequate education.

Additionally, girls also had limited access to education. During the colonial period, formal education was restricted to their male counterparts, while girls learned basic and domestic skills, such as needlework. In 1880, around half of U.S. colleges allowed women to attend. While this number continued to rise, it cannot be ignored that women were separated from educational opportunities as a means of control and maintaining a harmful societal expectation.

Challenging the System

They had to fight to get there, and while there have been many improvements, they still have to fight. The school system was designed in neglect of marginalized communities. To have Black students in these spaces disrupts their norm. To have girls in these spaces disrupts their norm. For students like these to be in these spaces, and furthermore, to challenge the authority, is to suggest that the white man’s world can be critiqued and even shattered. This disruption is necessary, but those in positions of power and those who uphold this norm do not like or want this change.

Previous
Previous

Age-Gated Internet or Government Expansionism?

Next
Next

The Rise of the “Trad-Wife” Aesthetic