Recently, there has been a growing trend on social media in which young influencers portray themselves as traditional women: getting married at a young age, staying home with the kids, cooking for their husbands, and keeping the house clean. Is this a product of feminism, with these women choosing to enact this lifestyle? Or is this a product of long-standing patriarchal values rebranded as personal choice?
How the “Trad-Wife” Trend Arose
In contrast to the “girlboss”, a “trad-wife” is a married woman who adheres to traditional gender roles and values. The “trad-wife” became popular during the pandemic, when people were forced to remain in their homes, so women were attempting to make the most of their situation. However, it has quickly turned into a controversial phenomenon. The rise and fall of such trends raise the question of what society generally values and what women are expected to do with their lives, given that trends, particularly those on social media, are attached to pressure, conformity, and appeal.
The Choice Argument
This phenomenon has sparked several debates about whether living this lifestyle upholds patriarchal values or if it is an embodiment of the choice that feminism advocates for and fought for. While, of course, many of these women are choosing to live this way (or at least portray themselves as such), there is something more concerning attached to this choice. Additionally, some of these women explicitly reject feminism.
Why This Is Harmful
Many women who adhere to this aesthetic online gain a lot of traction. When they get millions of views and several thousand comments, they can earn money from this. Thus, a “trad-wife influencer” is contradictory in itself because these women adhere to a stay-at-home role but make money from plastering this type of content online. In a way, they are selling the patriarchy and promoting it as pleasurable and aesthetically pleasing. Many of these influencers could be using this aesthetic for engagement purposes and may not actually live a life like this. In promoting this, everyday people think, “I should live this way too”; influencers are glamorizing a lifestyle that is not so glamorous to the average “trad-wife”.
The Aftermath of Being a “Trad-Wife”
In one of many testimonies reviewed by Cry Baby Kate, a former “trad-wife” reveals that she got a divorce after ten years of marriage. But when she was no longer married, she could not get an apartment or take out any loans on her own because she had no payment history. She stated that her husband’s name was on everything from the bank account to the house to the car, but her name was only on their son’s lunchbox, party invitations, and everything related to the kids and the home. This further emphasizes the harmful dynamic in this “trad-wife” sphere. Women become financially vulnerable after being subjected to control and having nothing for themselves. In another testimony, a woman revealed that as a former “trad-wife”, she had nothing for herself after the relationship. At 40 years old, she had to start over. She worked a part-time job making twelve dollars an hour while going to college full-time. Older women who were once “trad-wives” have shown us that it is difficult to get on your feet when you have been financially dependent on another person for your whole life.
What These Testimonies Tell Us
Financial abuse is a major aspect of what we don’t see in the “trad-wife” sphere. Those in “traditional” relationships, in this case, “trad-wives”, are at higher risk for this type of abuse because of their dependence on their husbands. This is because financial abuse involves one person (here, the husband) having all of the financial power over their dependent (here, the wife) and using this power to exert control. However, this is not the only issue we see in this lifestyle and in these kinds of relationships. While financial abuse is prevalent, other types of abuse, such as verbal and emotional abuse, are prevalent in these relationship dynamics due to rigid gender roles and expectations that reinforce harmful behavior.
It is also important to note that the negative elements of the “trad-wife” lifestyle are not isolated to abusive relationships. Embodying the “trad-wife” lifestyle and having no money and no prospects is harmful even if the relationship is not abusive. If the husband gets sick and passes away, loses his job, or even if the woman just wants to leave, the woman is then left with nothing because she was subjected to a lifestyle that did not allow her to obtain anything for herself.
Unfortunately, though, this is only revealed when women are out of the situation. Younger women who are just entering into this space are blinded by the appeal of a “simple life” and a life “dedicated to God”. The “trad-wife” aesthetic we see on social media often exists under Christian beliefs. Religion strengthens the appeal, thus making it more difficult for women to see how this lifestyle could hinder their future. It makes it harder to reject if God is involved.
The Future of Young Women
With this trend being most prominent among younger women, it is important to address these issues critically. While women have the choice to live a lifestyle they see fit, we must address the concerns and potential negative outcomes of those choices and ask ourselves who said choice truly benefits. Does being a “trad-wife” truly benefit a woman if she is overexerting herself and getting nothing in return? How about if she is left behind with nothing after a divorce? While these are not the only possible outcomes, and some “trad-wives” do lead happy lives, it is crucial to recognize that these negative outcomes are common and reflect a broader societal issue that could set us backwards.